James--Wow, what a dilemma. Many here have suggested wisely-do you really need a truck? A small wagon/crossover will yield much better mileage. Don't know how many miles you drive annually so that is a big factor.
That said, I love the way the Ridgeline drives.....like a limo. It's safe, handles well, and I average 19 to 20mpg as I don't commute in bumper to bumper traffic. I drive 12k miles per year, so the mpg difference isn't a huge deal. My 06 V-6 Tacoma 4 door did the same on gas.
We are biased here ya know
