View Single Post
  #17 (permalink)  
Old 05-14-2008, 12:25 PM
Cochise111 Cochise111 is offline
Senior Member
2006 White / Olive RTL
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: New Orleans area
Posts: 148
Re: EBC Brakes: FIRST set of brake pads in the USA

Quote:
Originally Posted by G2Turbo View Post
Of course I'm aware of what's on-line, as most people are-- just about everything. There's that side of the coin, then there is the practical reality.

That link is geared more towards racing and high performance. As mentioned only the most exotic cars use two piece rotors. Their criteria is narrow focused, and does not relate well to normal daily driven street cars using different pad compounds and rotors types. If anyone wants to take that as gospel for a normal street car then so be it. There will always be a difference between theoretical and practical effects- how something is used makes all the difference. Do not take this wrong: I respect Stop Tech and would in a moment mount them to any vehicle I own.

Next:

I've serviced many a fixed Honda rotor, and with your experience, ought to know they are NOT "irremovable". The shop owner I worked for years also thought the rotors did not come off until I showed him, how to (easily) remove the hub and remove the 4 bolts to free the rotor to be machined. I noticed you mentioned machining the rotors......

An interesting point you mention related to "bearing run-out". I don't recall ever seeing a TSB that stated this phenomenon, no matter the marque/brand. I'm not stating that it hasnt' been done. And previously mentioned that it couldn't have some influence, if a bearing was loose enough.

What gets me that an OEM would make this statement about "run out", to redirect the blame to another component. To me it sounds like a ploy, as you propose, to more or less state: "yes, we are aware of brake pedal pulsation complaints/problems, but it is not because of warped rotors".

Funny this. Well, yes, both Lexus and Toyota are wrong. Same company so there's really no difference. Throw Honda in there too. Feel free to show us any TSB or Recall or Campaign information to prove differently.

The reason I can say this is because of personal experience. Good 'ol real world stuff: My 2003 Toyota Tundra SR5 4x4 v8 TRD Access Cab had the warped rotor syndrome. It was under warranty, what did they do? They removed the rotors and machined them. Keep in mind the warranty is 3/36. Do you REALLY think, if loose bearings were the culprit, they wouldn't say anything? Do you also really think bearings on a low mileage new truck with barely 20K would become so loose so soon? Would they replace the bearings and tell me only the rotors were resurfaced? Would my service paperwork NOT have the actual work performed? Hmmm.

Next Case: Our 2006 Ridgeline. At 21K miles the brake pedal pulsates when stopping. Rotors are machined at Honda Dealership, as visibly apparent by looking at them, problem is gone. They slide right off, unlike the old design. Did Honda also replace my wheel bearings w/o notification? Doubtful, they wouldn't get the warranty labor credits. I also know the Service Manager a bit, and even interviewed with him once. His character is infallible and I would send any of my customers to know to him if needed.

Even more on the Ridge-- At 22.5K miles the rotors are warping again-- under normal no towing, easy driving highway miles, too. Ooops, I mean the brake pedal is pulsating again. Luckily the fancy brake parts finally arrived. Off come the old, on go the new. I even checked the hub bearings for looseness. Just like new. See where I'm going with this?

I've only driven on the new front rotors and pads for a day so far. Symptom? Gone. Just like that: changed rotors and pads. Voila.

Okay, so there's a trend. Is it only me? Does your vast experience become so easily swayed by what an OEM may say? Is it possible they are CYA'ing themselves to avoid admitting to a problem? Ever see TSB's on domestics for fuel injector problems? It's actually funny how they word them to say there's a perceived problem, and here's how to "fix" it, but otherwise deny the problem. Not everything in print is the honest truth.

If you want to say that adjusting bearings on your customer's vehicles fixes their brake pedal ossicilations, then great. If it works, wonderful. I'm not saying that whatever you do/have done doesn't work. I wasn't there. There are many variables to contend with. On old vehicles I'd probably agree with you a bit. However I'd say for the majority of brake problems, very, very few have been the cause of ONLY loose bearings. None that I know of, sorry.

Briefly: When a caliper squeezes the brake rotor, it runs true at that point, no matter how loose the bearing is. Seen it, tested it. The ONLY runout is perpendicular to the hub, or axially (up and down, not side to side). This vertical motion does NOT cause caliper piston kick back, like a warped rotor. It's easily verified: measure the thickness at various points with a caliper. Also: machine ONE side of the rotor, THEN the other. There is a drastic difference, easily seen in the pattern of the rotor. Visible evidence, measured evidence, real world verified by a test drive. I always test drive vehicles after repairs, like any good mechanic.

Your experience (for any tech) should allow you to reach conclusions based on actual experience and using powers of deduction, along with available technical information. Using this information, a real cause and effect answer should become obvious.

I don't mean to hammer on you, because this is more for those that are following along, wondering what the heck makes sense.

This is all I have time to say, so thanks for joining in.
Mighty Auto Parts --> Gimme a Brake

Just another opinion on whether heat causes "warped" rotors. As an aside, I've installed many slotted/cross-drilled rotors along with "high performance pads." Almost, without fail, the pedal oscillation/steering wheel shake returned. The only times it didn't return were in the cases where the vehicle was sold and I could no longer verify the "repair". I even attempted the high performance "fix" on my own vehicle only to have the vibration return after a couple of months. Granted, my 4Runner's rotors are very undersized, but when I resurfaced the rotors while installed on the vehicle the vibration was cured and hasn't returned. I was also very easy on my brakes. My brother in law now owns the 4Runner and still drives the vehicle in somewhat of a rough environment, and he has yet to feel rotor vibration.
Reply With Quote


Hey Guest!
Not Registered with the ROC? Register on our forums today!

Registration is FREE and you'll be joining the #1 Honda Ridgeline owner and enthusiast club in the world! You'll also be removing this ad, so please join the Ridgeline Owners Club today!