hofffam
04-19-2006, 12:26 PM
My audio upgrade is about complete. I included a few pictures – but they are not intended to show a disassembled RL interior. Those pictures have been posted already by others and were very helpful. My system is not as elaborate as mugen1’s, djdj’s or a few others here on ROC. For example there is no DVD/video or NAV capability. My goal was to dramatically improve the clarity and range of the sound in the RL. I originally planned to keep the factory 6-disc HU and integrate to the rest of the system with an Audiocontrol LC6 line output converter. But I changed my mind because I was uncertain whether the outputs of the Honda HU were equalized or not. I considered a JL Audio Cleansweep but it cost more than a new head unit and I didn’t want a separate volume control. I also wanted MP3 playback and the Honda MP3 player is ridiculously priced. So I decided to replace the factory 6-disc changer headunit with an Alpine unit.
One thing I did differently than most ROCers: I used full active crossovers instead of passive. I prefer component speakers over coaxes, and I prefer the flexibility provided by active crossovers. Active crossovers often offer steeper crossover slopes than passive, and they also put nothing but wire between the amplifier and speaker. The cost isn’t as high as some might think – because 4 way amps are widely available and by comparison good passive crossovers are not cheap. A 24 db/octave passive crossover could be expensive if you use good coils and capacitors. Active crossovers should be accessible for adjustments – not behind the rear seat.
I’m kind of anti-bling and somewhat frugal. So I didn’t buy speakers from normal autosound brands. I’m not impressed with many of them – especially the emphasis on cosmetics and gimmicks (like 4-way coaxes). Just my two cents. I didn’t want to spend a bunch of money so some of my components were purchased used on ebay.
My component list:
Alpine CDA-9853 headunit, bought from Crutchfield for $269 including dash kit, wiring harness, and antenna adapter. I picked this HU because it has a fully programmable crossover, time compensation, parametric EQ, and MP3/WMA capability. It supports steering wheel controls. It is also a closeout right now which explains the great price.
Alpine MRV-F307 4x50W amplifier; drives front tweeters and rear speakers; amp mounted behind the rear seat
Alpine MRV-F340 4x55W amplifier; drives front mid-bass and subwoofer (bridged); amp mounted behind the rear seat
Audiocontrol 3XS crossover, used to crossover between tweeters and mid-bass; mounted under the passenger seat so I can adjust it without removing the rear seat
Vifa P17WJ 6½ inch mid-bass – 4 ohm version of highly regarded home audio drivers; I have previous experience with this driver in another vehicle, very smooth midrange
Vifa D26NC05 soft dome autosound tweeter – I used it before in another vehicle; mounted on the door frames exactly where you’d expect it.
Parts Express Reference Series 10 inch High Output subwoofer – described already in another thread; in a sealed box mounted under the rear seat
Rear speakers are factory; maybe I’ll replace them someday with good coaxes
Stinger Helix (mostly) interconnects, directional twisted pair
Stinger 4 ga. and 8 ga. power/ground wiring; 16 ga. speaker cable (nothing special)
PAC SWI-ALP – steering wheel control adapter (not hooked up yet)
Cascade Audio Engineering VG2 sound dampening material on front doors
The Alpine HU is used in 2-way crossover mode, not 3-way, because I wanted fader control of the rear. The Alpine HU crossover feeds signals below 100hz to the sub amp, rear signals above 100hz to the rear amp, and front signals above 100hz to the Audiocontrol crossover, which splits the signal at 2.66Khz to the tweeters and mid-bass. One common design point for a tweeter crossover frequency is at least one octave above its free air resonance – which provides some power handling capacity. For this tweeter that frequency would be about 3500hz. Because the 3XS uses 24 db/octave crossovers I pushed the crossover down slightly in frequency. Pushing it down makes the sound a bit less dependent on direct sound from the mid-bass drivers.
A couple of installation notes and general comments on results:
There is a good deal of room behind the rear seat but the depth shrinks considerably as you move up from the bottom. The picture below of the amp board shows the MRV-F340 (right amp) mounted in “portrait” style – chosen to face the wiring to the left. I learned later that it was too thick at the top and I couldn’t reinstall the rear seat. So I had to re-mount the amp “landscape” style – not shown in the picture.
Interconnnects from the HU to the center of the rear seat need to be 14-15 ft. long, not 12 ft – if you plan to run wires the long way around. I carefully (so I thought!) estimated 12 ft, planning to route the wire under the door sills. I was forced to “cut the corner” and run the wires under the rear floor from the door pillars to the amps. Oh well.
I ran 4ga power through the grommet above+right of the gas pedal. Worked great.
When I removed the door panels no more than 1/3 of the white snaps stayed on the door. I used curved electronics forceps to pop them out.
I ran new speaker wire into the driver’s door by cutting a slot in the door frame right next to the white wiring connector. I cut the slot with my Dremel. The wire goes through the factory rubber boot. Thanks mugen1 for the advice on running wire through the boot.
The front mid-bass speakers are mounted in place of the factory speakers with spacers I made from ¾ inch MDF. The spacers are painted for protection from moisture and are screwed directly to the door frame. The speakers are screwed to the spacers with 8x3/4 inch stainless screws. I use rope putty as gasket material because it is a bit sticky and seals very well.
Even with ¾ inch MDF spacers my mid-bass drivers were a bit too wide a relaxed fit with the existing door holes. I had to carefully rotate the mid-bass drivers to align their narrowest part to align with the factory cutout.
My tweeter mounts needed more depth than available in the plastic door pieces so I had to create 1/8 inch thick ring spacers. It looks better than I thought it would.
I have not yet hooked up the rear speakers. I plan to use the factory wiring. Anyone know the polarity of the factory wiring? I plan to tap in at the door pillars.
The front doors vibrate much less than before. I don’t think it is as much about sound dampening as it is not running low bass to those speakers.
With no special effort the system has no noise or grounding problems. Perhaps those twisted pair interconnects really are better. Thanks to eshuerger for pointing out the fuzzy directional indicators.
I’m still tuning/tweaking, but the sound is dramatically better. I thought the factory system had schizophrenic bass – sometimes sounded reasonably balanced, other times thick and slow. I think the factory sub is OK, but the door speakers were run full range, which overlapped the sub, causing the thick sound. The treble always sounded soft or distant, even with the treble turned up. My system is not designed to boom. I listen to blues, jazz, and a variety of rock. The bass is very clean and has good pitch definition. One mark of a good system is that it encourages you to play lots of music, and loud. I’ve been doing that constantly…..
Sorry for the long post. Thanks to mugen1, djdj, and others for their posts and pictures.
One thing I did differently than most ROCers: I used full active crossovers instead of passive. I prefer component speakers over coaxes, and I prefer the flexibility provided by active crossovers. Active crossovers often offer steeper crossover slopes than passive, and they also put nothing but wire between the amplifier and speaker. The cost isn’t as high as some might think – because 4 way amps are widely available and by comparison good passive crossovers are not cheap. A 24 db/octave passive crossover could be expensive if you use good coils and capacitors. Active crossovers should be accessible for adjustments – not behind the rear seat.
I’m kind of anti-bling and somewhat frugal. So I didn’t buy speakers from normal autosound brands. I’m not impressed with many of them – especially the emphasis on cosmetics and gimmicks (like 4-way coaxes). Just my two cents. I didn’t want to spend a bunch of money so some of my components were purchased used on ebay.
My component list:
Alpine CDA-9853 headunit, bought from Crutchfield for $269 including dash kit, wiring harness, and antenna adapter. I picked this HU because it has a fully programmable crossover, time compensation, parametric EQ, and MP3/WMA capability. It supports steering wheel controls. It is also a closeout right now which explains the great price.
Alpine MRV-F307 4x50W amplifier; drives front tweeters and rear speakers; amp mounted behind the rear seat
Alpine MRV-F340 4x55W amplifier; drives front mid-bass and subwoofer (bridged); amp mounted behind the rear seat
Audiocontrol 3XS crossover, used to crossover between tweeters and mid-bass; mounted under the passenger seat so I can adjust it without removing the rear seat
Vifa P17WJ 6½ inch mid-bass – 4 ohm version of highly regarded home audio drivers; I have previous experience with this driver in another vehicle, very smooth midrange
Vifa D26NC05 soft dome autosound tweeter – I used it before in another vehicle; mounted on the door frames exactly where you’d expect it.
Parts Express Reference Series 10 inch High Output subwoofer – described already in another thread; in a sealed box mounted under the rear seat
Rear speakers are factory; maybe I’ll replace them someday with good coaxes
Stinger Helix (mostly) interconnects, directional twisted pair
Stinger 4 ga. and 8 ga. power/ground wiring; 16 ga. speaker cable (nothing special)
PAC SWI-ALP – steering wheel control adapter (not hooked up yet)
Cascade Audio Engineering VG2 sound dampening material on front doors
The Alpine HU is used in 2-way crossover mode, not 3-way, because I wanted fader control of the rear. The Alpine HU crossover feeds signals below 100hz to the sub amp, rear signals above 100hz to the rear amp, and front signals above 100hz to the Audiocontrol crossover, which splits the signal at 2.66Khz to the tweeters and mid-bass. One common design point for a tweeter crossover frequency is at least one octave above its free air resonance – which provides some power handling capacity. For this tweeter that frequency would be about 3500hz. Because the 3XS uses 24 db/octave crossovers I pushed the crossover down slightly in frequency. Pushing it down makes the sound a bit less dependent on direct sound from the mid-bass drivers.
A couple of installation notes and general comments on results:
There is a good deal of room behind the rear seat but the depth shrinks considerably as you move up from the bottom. The picture below of the amp board shows the MRV-F340 (right amp) mounted in “portrait” style – chosen to face the wiring to the left. I learned later that it was too thick at the top and I couldn’t reinstall the rear seat. So I had to re-mount the amp “landscape” style – not shown in the picture.
Interconnnects from the HU to the center of the rear seat need to be 14-15 ft. long, not 12 ft – if you plan to run wires the long way around. I carefully (so I thought!) estimated 12 ft, planning to route the wire under the door sills. I was forced to “cut the corner” and run the wires under the rear floor from the door pillars to the amps. Oh well.
I ran 4ga power through the grommet above+right of the gas pedal. Worked great.
When I removed the door panels no more than 1/3 of the white snaps stayed on the door. I used curved electronics forceps to pop them out.
I ran new speaker wire into the driver’s door by cutting a slot in the door frame right next to the white wiring connector. I cut the slot with my Dremel. The wire goes through the factory rubber boot. Thanks mugen1 for the advice on running wire through the boot.
The front mid-bass speakers are mounted in place of the factory speakers with spacers I made from ¾ inch MDF. The spacers are painted for protection from moisture and are screwed directly to the door frame. The speakers are screwed to the spacers with 8x3/4 inch stainless screws. I use rope putty as gasket material because it is a bit sticky and seals very well.
Even with ¾ inch MDF spacers my mid-bass drivers were a bit too wide a relaxed fit with the existing door holes. I had to carefully rotate the mid-bass drivers to align their narrowest part to align with the factory cutout.
My tweeter mounts needed more depth than available in the plastic door pieces so I had to create 1/8 inch thick ring spacers. It looks better than I thought it would.
I have not yet hooked up the rear speakers. I plan to use the factory wiring. Anyone know the polarity of the factory wiring? I plan to tap in at the door pillars.
The front doors vibrate much less than before. I don’t think it is as much about sound dampening as it is not running low bass to those speakers.
With no special effort the system has no noise or grounding problems. Perhaps those twisted pair interconnects really are better. Thanks to eshuerger for pointing out the fuzzy directional indicators.
I’m still tuning/tweaking, but the sound is dramatically better. I thought the factory system had schizophrenic bass – sometimes sounded reasonably balanced, other times thick and slow. I think the factory sub is OK, but the door speakers were run full range, which overlapped the sub, causing the thick sound. The treble always sounded soft or distant, even with the treble turned up. My system is not designed to boom. I listen to blues, jazz, and a variety of rock. The bass is very clean and has good pitch definition. One mark of a good system is that it encourages you to play lots of music, and loud. I’ve been doing that constantly…..
Sorry for the long post. Thanks to mugen1, djdj, and others for their posts and pictures.