I own a 2007 RTL with 153k miles on it. It's been the best vehicle I've ever owned. The updates to the 2011 may be nice, but it's still the same basic vehicle. If the timing belt or radiator replacement haven't been done on the '07 yet, work that into the negotiation. You know you're going to have to have them done pretty much directly after you buy it. So, factor in that $800-1000 for the TB and $400 or so for the radiator. The '11 won't be too far behind that with the mileage that's on it.
If you have a pet and a little one on the way (as do I), leather is a no-brainer. My dog had a motion sickness problem when she was a pup and would upchuck and drool all over the seats. They always cleaned up easily with no residue. That cannot be said for the fabric in the RTS. Also keep in mind that the RTL has heated seats. If you live anywhere that gets even moderately cold, it's one of the greatest features ever.
With the positives that the '07 offers as well as the maintenance hisotry, that would be my choice. Plus, you can negotiate strongly and pocket even more that $5000 for diapers. You're going to need it. Whatever dealership is selling that '07, they likely don't have more than $11k in that truck.
If you have a pet and a little one on the way (as do I), leather is a no-brainer. My dog had a motion sickness problem when she was a pup and would upchuck and drool all over the seats. They always cleaned up easily with no residue. That cannot be said for the fabric in the RTS. Also keep in mind that the RTL has heated seats. If you live anywhere that gets even moderately cold, it's one of the greatest features ever.
With the positives that the '07 offers as well as the maintenance hisotry, that would be my choice. Plus, you can negotiate strongly and pocket even more that $5000 for diapers. You're going to need it. Whatever dealership is selling that '07, they likely don't have more than $11k in that truck.