I have MaxSpyder mats in both our vehicles and love them but I do wish I could find some mats like I had in my truck back in the early 2000s. I think maybe Lund made them but they were this really heavily scotchguarded fabric on top of an all weather liner. They looked like carpet but you could get them as dirty as you wanted and just hose them off at the car wash. They stopped making them and I haven't found anything like them since.I think they're made of soft rubber, right? I like the feel of that, like we have in our SUV.
I have Maxspyder mats and they're great for full coverage/protection, but they are hard plastic - I think all the full-coverage ones are - and there's not a square centimeter of carpet in sight, so they feel a little too "utilitarian" after a while. Then again, no doubt my carpet is perfect under there .