Yes, I wasn't happy with the Wrangler I owned (2012 Sahara 2dr, purchased new)... and I ranted about it on this forum. Because I put so many miles on my vehicles I do tend to trade them in fairly frequently... but at least I waited to 70-80K miles on each of my three Ridgeline's because I liked them so much. Even though my Wrangler was a POS (and I agree, individual vehicles vary and anybody can get a lemon), it held its value on trade just like the RL's have for me, so I didn't get burned. And I agree with eurban's comments above regarding poor mileage, poor daily driver ride, etc. for the wrangler. If the Jeep pickup is more like the wrangler than the GC in terms of ride and handling (likely) I won't look at it. But if it looks like the wrangler and drives like the GC (similarly to the current RL, which gets significantly better mileage than the RL, possibly because of the 8spd transmission), I'd definitely take a look. Like another poster said earlier, the competition is a good thing for those of us who are fans of the RL and gen2 RL.