I just purchased and installed the Weathertech on my 2019. I debated for several weeks after reading posts from G1 and G2. I must say I love it!! It reduces the wind noise substancially while still allowing great air flow. I blocks some of the superbright sunlight. It fit well and was an easy install. At $60 it was half the price of OEM and didn't cost a crazy amount to ship. As far as appearence that is very personal. I like function and don't feel this detracts from my pearl Ridgy.