Insert Jon Stewart-esque "Go onnnnnnn" from the Daily Show here... Please compare and contrast your RTL-E experiences vs. the latest-gen Tacoma you owned and sold after Toyota said forearm-numbing steering wheel vibrations & untraceable resonances were "working as designed."
Don't be modest. Whatever you can share that helps steer people toward the better vehicle is a huge help.
Well, I have compared it elsewhere; however, here are a few highlights:
Compared to the Taco, the RL has an amazingly smooth ride and drivetrain. Taco wasn't loud inside; however, wasn't truly quiet like the RL. The cruise on the Taco was useless due to poor trans programming. The Taco needed RPM's to get out of it's own way, and when there, it was quite noisy. The RL shifts smoothly and has power on the lower end of the RPM scale, where the Taco doesn't. The Taco had a horrible driving position, and on top of that, you couldn't adjust the seat or steering wheel much at all to get comfortable....and this was on the 'Limited', where little things like no glovebox light just added to the frustration. Taco handles 'like a truck' in the corners. RL is much tighter in the corners and will take them much faster and more securely. RL has better room in the back seat; however, I wish the rear doors opened wider, like the Toyota. RL bed is easier to use, since it's flat. Love the bed-trunk. Toyota is easier to load and I did like the Taco's buffered tailgate.
RL has Garmin GPS built in. Taco has Toyota proprietary system which called for $180 map updates yearly if you wanted to stay up-to-date. RL gives you 5 years of updates for free, and says 'minimal' cost for after that...(we shall see what minimal actually is, though). Entune on the Taco is a fair system. The HondaLink has it's own quirks, so I would say this is a wash, except for the map issue, which is a Honda win all the way.
Mileage? I reported elsewhere that I could NEVER get the Taco over 20mpg. I have an 800+ mile loop I drive for work and when I drove the Taco on that loop last year, averaged 19.1 vs 24.6 (IIRC) on the same loop with the RL this past month. RL had A/C on the entire trip. Taco trip was in November in cooler weather without A/C. Cruising at 80 mph in the RL is effortless...you could tell the Taco was working hard at 80 and required much more attention just to stay there through the rolling hills of I-40. Arriving at my various locations, I was much less stressed from driving the RL than the Taco....and that, in and of itself, is huge.......not to mention the BIGGEST GRIPE:
Between 2100-2400RPM, there is a horrible buzzy vibration in the steering wheel of the V6 Tacoma. It is worse on some than others; however, it is there on every one I've driven. The issue was immediately reported to Toyota and the dealer and fully investigated. IT IS STILL THERE ON THE '17's! Toyota did nothing to correct this. My hands and lower arms would go numb on longer drives due to the vibration. Toyota legal and the dealer's response was "functions as designed." The engineers pointed to the hard rubber engine mounts and a one-piece exhaust manifold as the culprits. No TSB has ever been issued and it flummoxes me to believe that they wouldn't at least fix this issue (well documented by many on several forums) on the next model year. There are many posts of others who, like me, got rid of their '16 Taco due to this issues, and this issue, alone. A major biff on Toyota's part......heck, they re-programmed the Trans with a TSB that supposedly helps the shifting problem...but couldn't or wouldn't fix what, to me, is a deal breaker? Made no sense; however, that is the main reason why I dumped the Taco at a loss and will not consider a Toyota, again. Not saying that Honda wouldn't reply with the same firewall; however, with both the manufacturer and dealer basically telling me to stuff my issue, I've lost faith in Toyota as a company after owning several over the years.
Other Taco plusses: Handled quite well in 4WD with snow tires on board. Can't speak to the RL until winter on this issue; however, my snow tires are on order. I drive lots of fire roads and, so far, the RL has done a great job. Looked decent and more 'truck like'; however, I've gotten used to the softer front on the RL. The rest is minor, like having an accessible spare if the bed is loaded. I never towed with the Taco, so I can't address that as an issue. A lot of things are personal, so I will leave that and the minor things, to the reader to decide.
Well, there you have it. IMHO, the 'new' G3 Taco is just a failed G2.5 update and not a true re-design at all....now, if they would have put the 4.0L from the FJ in there..............(full disclosure: I owned an FJ for 6 years and it was far superior in every way to the Tacoma in terms of smoothness, mileage, performance, etc. On-road handling? IMO, better than the Taco....just sayin'....)
HTH