I would think you could sell your Taco locally or on Craigslist pretty quickly. They are a very popular truck that is #1 in holding resale value. Like the Ridgeline, there are many who prefer Gen2 as much as the Gen2.5.If you decide you want the silver, that would make the second red RTL-E in the area that I'm aware of.
My biggest hurdle to getting a Ridgeline turned out to be something I didn't expect: trying to sell or trade my immaculate 2013 Toyota Tacoma 4X4 Double Cab Limited with only 6000 mi. Honda dealers seem to look askance at pickup trucks. The few I've talked to haven't been very close to KBB dealer trade-in value. My Tacoma is a real standout but people have to see it to get that. ...