I had a 96 Ranger 4.0 V-6 with a 5 sp and absolutely loved driving it. With a 3/4 drop it sat about like a Civic and looked smaller than my friend, the German teacher, at school's VW Beetle looked bigger and I think it may have actually been wider. Negative on the Ranger was the stiff towing package suspension, positive was that it stuck like glue in corners with the 235 wide 15" wheels. But the new small trucks were no where near as cool looking and it seemed like everything was jacked up 4wd. Then the Ranger had some issues and I sold it.
In looking around the small Fords were ugly-plain looking, Maverick or Ranger, and the Hyundai was just plain too small. My son-in-law works at Honda in robotics engineering and had a Pilot RTL trim and pointed me to the Ridgeline. I drove one and it absolutely was a great ride. Better than the HR-V we have and I think the Civic we had, wish the HR-V had the turbo 1500 the Civic had. I'd have loved that! But I digress...
Yeah the Ridgeline may have cost more, I got the RTL for a variety of reasons but could have lived without the sun roof (never opened the one on the HR-V yet and never while driving the Civic. Just don't care for them. Same with the sliding rear window. I'd have been happier if it had been rear wheel drive for the fun of spinning donuts, but that's life.
The only real negative in my book for my Ridgeline is that it really is big. No where near as easy to park as the old Ranger, Civic, and, obviously, the HR-V. When we go anywhere that may require parallel parking we take the HR-V. I'm not sure the Ridgeline would even fit in many of the city parking spaces. I'm pulling 16-18 mpg when towing a 900 lb trailer full of my wife's craft stuff depending on how hilly the terrain is. Pulling the utility trailer, 600 lb, with a 400 lb bike is no sweat and definitely goes better than 18 mpg. Love the trunk and the spacious interior.
All in all, putting similar equipment on the low buck base trucks others make puts them up close enough to the Ridgeline that I spent the extra and have no regrets doing so.