Now that I've had the truck about 10 weeks and 2500 miles I thought I would post my thoughts on owning my first Ridgeline as well as some comparisons to other vehicles that I've owned or driven. I'm hoping my thoughts maybe useful to others who may be looking into buying one. Sorry if it's a little long.
Background
My last vehicle was a 2014 Z71 Silverado with a 5.3 engine. I bought it new and had about 92k miles on it when I sold it. Overall I think it was a good vehicle but 2014 wasn't the best year for the Silverado(first year of a new design). 2014's are known for electrical problems, bad AC compressors, and transmission failures. I had none of those issues but did experience a cracked radiator at about 50k miles and the exhaust manifolds started leaking about about 90k miles(another common issue with GM trucks). A friend with the same year Silverado just replaced the transmission in his at 120k miles. I was concerned about some expensive repairs in the near future so I started to look at new trucks.
New Truck Selection
I didn't want or need another full size truck. I had asperations of buying a car trailer and hauling a race car when I bought the Silverado. I never bought the trailer and sold the race car. I do own a house and work on cars for a hobby so I do occasionally haul a lawnmower, furniture, wood or an engine so I thought a midsize truck would be a good option. I looked at the Tacoma, and the new Colorado/Canyon. I'm not sold on the long reliability of the new 4 cylinder turbo engine in the Colorado/Canyon but I do think they look great. I like the Tacoma, my dad has one that I have driven and ridden in a lot. I think they are very reliable but a little dated and over priced. Dealers in my area had none in stock and wanted over MSRP. If I hadn't got a Ridgeline I most likely would have gotten a Tacoma. I test drove a 23 Ridgeline RTL and was surprised by how much I liked it. The Ridgeline has a smoother ride and better handling than any of the other options I looked at so I decided on a Ridgeline. Maybe I'm biased but I don't much care for Fords or Nissans...too many quality/reliability issues(in my opinion) so I never seriously considered a Ranger, Maverick, or Frontier.
Once I decided on a Ridgeline I looked at the RTL and Sport. For the money the Sport offered the features I cared most about. I view my daily driver truck as basic transportation, I don't really want or need a lot of tech gadgets. I'm mostly concerned with reliability and being practical for how I use it. I prefer the wheels and black trim on the Sport vs the chrome trim and grey wheels on the RTL. If money wasn't a factor a Black Edition would be nice(all the gadgets and black trim). The one thing I wish the sport had is the blind spot monitoring but it's not a big deal to me.
No local dealers had any Sports in stock. I found a sport for $2650 below MSRP with no dealer add-ons at a dealership a couple hours away. They initially wanted to charge for locking lug nuts, mud flaps, all weather floor mats but I declined. They left the locking lug nuts and mud flaps on at no extra cost. I sold my Silverado to Carvana for $4k more than any dealer was offering. I feel like I did well selling my old truck and got the new one at a good price which made my decision to buy easier.
My thoughts on the Ridgeline - The Good
I'm happy with the purchase so I'll start with the good. I love the tailgate and trunk, both of those features are outstanding and give you more options for hauling or storing. The ride is smooth and quiet, by far the best riding truck I've ever driven. I think the seats and driving position are comfortable. The rear seats are comfortable for my 16yo daughter and it's nice having the separate rear temperature controls. I like how the rear seats fold up too, it's simple and easy. I like how the seatbelts are attached to a rod to keep them from getting stuck in or under the seat when folding/unfolding them (that is an issue in my Dad's Tacoma).
I'm happy with the performance, I don't consider the Ridgeline fast but it has enough get up and go. It feels a little sluggish compared to the Silverado at low RPM but I think the Ridgeline is probably quicker overall once you get into the upper RPM range. The VCM system seems to work well, I can very rarely tell when it switches between 6 and 3 cylinders. I may try a S-VCM controller at some point. I hated the DOD system on my Silverado and deleted that feature via HP Tuners..it wasn't very smooth when switching between 4 and 8 cylinders.
I've read that some people don't like the 9 speed or feel like it's hunting for gears. I can't say that I have experienced that, it feels very solid to me.
The all wheel drive system works great, I've been impressed with it. It's nice to not have to switch between 2WD and 4WD modes. It will be interesting to try it in the snow later this year.
I've averaged 23.0 mpg so far with a mix of city and highway driving, I'm happy with that. I'm anxious to take a trip on the highway to see if I can get 25+mpg.
I like the Lunar Silver Metallic color. It's just a personal preference but it looks great and hides dirt much better than most other colors. White was my 2nd color choice.
My thoughts on the Ridgeline - Just Ok
I would prefer the arm rest was bigger, I think it would be more comfortable that way, but it's no deal breaker for me. I'm not a big person but I can see where a larger person could find the arm rest uncomfortable.
I feel like the parking brake is in a strange location, I occasionally bump into it with my foot when getting in or out.
I don't use the Auto Start/Stop system. I find it annoying that it defaults back to on each time you start the truck. Once in a while I forget to turn it off then get surprised when it turns off when waiting at a stop light. I will eventually get an idle stopper so I won't have to deal with it anymore.
The auto high beams work well under certain conditions but not others. It can be frustratingly inconsistent. I may turn off the auto high beams.
As with most new vehicles I feel like the paint quality isn't very good. It has some orange peel and there is some inconsistency in the metallic in the paint. Not enough that most people would notice but I can see it when looking closely at it in certain lighting conditions. The Silverado factory paint was much better. The Tacoma paint is about the same quality as the Ridgeline.
My thoughts on the Ridgeline - Not so Good
My biggest complaint is that the doors on my truck rattle, mainly the driver door. They don't always rattle but on county roads with a rougher pavement and cracks it was pretty frequent. On other types of roads it wasn't too bad. I adjusted the door stops out a little which seemed to help a lot but I was still getting some noise. I read on another forum that sometimes it helps to apply silicone grease or some type of dressing to the door seals to eliminate noise. I applied some Chemical Guys VRP to the door seals and now the door rattle/squeak noise is almost non existent surprisingly. I think I got this issue resolved but I feel like you shouldn't have to do anything to a brand new vehicle.
It gets mentioned all the time but the infotainment system is a little clunky and dated. It gets the job done but that's about it. I've only had it lock up once when using a map program through my phone so I haven't had any major issues.
Overall Impressions
Overall I'm very happy with the purchase especially now that I've got the door noise issue resolved. I like the looks of the latest Ridgelines and it meets my needs perfectly. It can haul anything that I would need, is super comfortable, rides great and gets reasonably good gas mileage. The ride, handling, trunk, and tailgate set the Ridgeline apart from the others for me. The Ridgeline isn't perfect but it's good points out weigh the negative by a lot. It's truly a pleasure to drive and much more enjoyable than expected.